Updated July 18, 2024
As voted on Twitter in July 2024.
Italics – signature sandwich
Personal Barred in DC ranking of best quality sandwich shops:
- Bub and Pop’s
- Stachowski’s
- Bar Boheme
- Italian sandwiches: Salumeria 2703
[If you like this content, which barely gets any ad revenue, please consider supporting Barred in DC’s Patreon, which provides absolutely no benefits except perhaps me doing more of these]
PLATINUM TIER
60%+ who’ve eaten say one of Best in DC. 92%+ fans.
- Bub and Pop’s (Dupont)
- Tue-Sat 11a-7p
- Hot and cold Philly-style hoagies
- Bub’s Italian Hoagie is most popular; Pop’s Beef Brisket or The Philly Special are also standouts
- $16-17 for most on 10 inch housemade roll dusted with sesame and polenta
- Much more expensive if you order online/delivery via apps. Recommend to call ahead to order, no indoor seating
- 2013
- 62% say one of best in DC, 96% are fans, ranked 2nd out of 4th when compared to other Platinum Tier, slightly higher than A. Litteri H2H. 66% have eaten
- Stachowski’s Market (Georgetown)
- Mon-Sat 10a-8p; Sun 10a-6p
- More traditional
- Hot Pastrami
- $24 for pastrami, mostly $15-18 for rest
- 2012
- 66% say one of best in DC, 96% are fans, ranked 4th out of 4th when compared to other Platinum Tier. 58% have eaten
- A. Litteri (Union Market aera)
- Sun-Mon 11a-6p, Tue-Sat 9a-6p
- Italian-style
- Italian Classic
- ~$7 (6 inch), $9.25 (9 inch), $12 (12 inch)
- 1926 (~1988 sandwiches)
- 61% say one of best in DC, 96% are fans, ranked 1st out of 4th when compared to other Platinum Tier, slightly below Bub & Pop’s H2H. 61% have eaten
- Mangialardo’s (Capitol Hill / Hill East)
- M-F 8a-3p; closed Sat-Sun
- Italian-style
- G-Man
- ~$13
- 1953 (late 1960s sandwiches)
- 65% say one of best in DC, 92% are fans, ranked 3rd out of 4th when compared to other Platinum Tier. 49% have eaten
GOLD TIER
At least half of people who’ve eaten at one of these places say it’s one of best in DC. 90%+ are fans
- Your Only Friend (Shaw)
- W-Sat 11a-10p, Sun 11a-9p (or sell out) (kitchen hours)
- Eclectic, full bar too, open later
- Chicky Pep. No 2, RPG
- $16
- 2023
- 53% say one of best in DC, 90% are fans. 41% have eaten.
- Salumeria 2703 (Brookland & NoMa)
- Closed Tuesdays, open 11a other days, close at 7p other wkdys, 8p Fri-Sat
- Italian-style
- Sopressata
- $15
- 2016
- 53% say one of best in DC, 92% are fans. Only 16% have eaten
- Neopol Savory Smokery (Union Market)
- M-W 11a-8p, Th-F 11a-9p, Sat 8a-9p, Sun 8a-7p
- Smoked seafood (mostly) sandwiches
- Smoked Salmon BLT
- $13
- 2014
- 51% say one of best in DC, 93% are fans. Only 25% have eaten
- Compliments Only (Dupont)
- 10:30a-6p daily
- Eclectic
- Crunchy Boi
- $15
- 2022
- 50% say one of best in DC, 91% are fans. Whopping 69% have eaten
SILVER TIER
At least 1/3 say one of best in DC
- Vace (Cleveland Park)
- M-Th, Sat 9a-8p, F 9a-9p, Sun 10a-5p
- Classic Italian style
- Italian Cold Cut
- $8-9
- 1976
- 34% say one of best in DC, whopping 93% are fans. 36% have eaten
- Wisemiller’s Deli (Georgetown)
- 8a-10p daily
- Chicken Madness
- $10
- Before 1949 (current owner 1982)
- 39% say one of best in DC, 89% are fans. 27% have eaten
- Sundevich (Shaw, Capitol Hill-ish)
- Shaw – 11a-4p daily, CH – 11a-3p, closed Sun
- International themed sandwiches
- Kingston
- $15-$16
- 2011
- 39% say one of best in DC; 90% are fans. 69% have eaten
- Grazie Grazie (Downtown, The Wharf)
- 11a-8p (The Wharf), 11a-9p (Downtown) daily
- Cheesesteaks and Italian sandwiches
- 8+1 or Minelli
- $15-$16.50
- 2019
- 38% say one of best in DC; 90% are fans. 67% have eaten
- The Best Sandwich Place (Downtown – 2 locations)
- Cornercopia (Navy Yard)
- 9a-5p M-F
- Standard deli
- Stadium is popular
- $10-12ish
- 36% say one of best in DC; 86% are fans; 21% have eaten
- Subb’s by Carl (Woodridge)
- 9a-4:55p, closed Sun
- Italian-style
- Genoa Salami (#1)
- $10
- 1987
- Cash only, can call ahead
- Little controversial – 42% who’ve eaten say one of best in DC, but 25% aren’t fans. Only 10% have eaten
- Wagshal’s (AU Park, Spring Valley)
- Main Deli- M-F 8a-8:30p, Sat 9a-8:30p, Sun 9a-7:30p. other location opens at 9a daily, closes 8p on wkdys and 7p wknds
- Traditional deli
- Smoked brisket (Montreal-style). Also very good is pastrami
- $14.50
- 1925, current location 1938, current owners 1990
- 35% say one of best in DC, 87% are fans, 40% have eaten
- Bar Boheme (Union Market)
- Noon-8p daily
- Traditional/International inspired
- Tachhino
- $16
- 2023
- 34% say one of best in DC, 85% are fans, Only 18% have been
- Bagels, etc. (Dupont)
- M-Sat 6a-4p, Sun 6a-3p
- non-bagel sandwiches rated only
- Turkey avocado
- $11-12
- Cash only
- 36% say one of best in DC, but 22% aren’t fans. 28% have eaten
- Deli City (Langdon)
- M-F 6a-4:30p, closed wknds
- Diner style
- Hot pastrami, corned beef, or reuben
- $9-10ish
- current location 1979
- 35% say one of best in DC, but 30% aren’t fans. Only 5% have eaten
BRONZE TIER
- Market Lunch (Eastern Market)
- MGM Roast Beef (Brentwood)
- So’s Your Mom (Adams Morgan)
- Each Peach Market (Mt. Pleasant)
- Jettie’s (Downtown, Chevy Chase, Foxhall, Cathedral Heights)
- Al Volo Stand (Farmers markets include Dupont, Foggy Bottom, and City Center)
- Harvey’s Market (Union Market)
- Capo Deli (Foggy Bottom, Shaw)
- Nido (Mt. Pleasant)
- District Fishwife (Union Market)
- Loeb’s Deli (Downtown)
- GW Deli (Foggy Bottom)
- Simply Banh Mi (Georgetown)
- Dupont Market (Dupont)
OTHER WORTH KNOWING ABOUT
Mother Ruckers, MLK Deli, Canales Deli in Eastern Market, Porchetta District, Old City Market & Oven, Uncle Chip’s, Italian Gourmet Deli, Fight Club, Duke’ Grocery, Al’s Deli, Taylor Gourmet, Colada Shop, Call Your Mother Deli
Others Nominated with at least 60% fans: City Place Cafe, Sunrise Cafe, Ampersandwich, San’dwich Lorenzeo at San Lorenzo, Delizique, Broad Branch Market, Prego Again, Aurora Market, Beresovsky’s Deli, Atrium Cafe, Carving Room Noma, Breadsoda, Prego Deli, Bozellis’
Barred in DC 
Leave a comment